We Were Liars
E. Lockhart
Hot Key Books
ISBN 9781471403989
This is a beautifully-written book which paints a detailed and intricate picture of family life and relations. It describes the long summers of the Sinclair family spent on their own private island in Massachusetts, USA. The Grandparents have the big house, and their three daughters each have a separate house round the island where they spend each summer with their own families. The Liars of the title are Cady who narrates the story, her two cousins Mirren and Johnny, and Gat who is Johnny's step father's nephew and first comes to the island when they are all eight. For the Liars, they are paradise holidays spent running free, swimming in the sparkling sea, chatting under the stars with their cousins and playing tennis. However a dark thread runs through this idyllic world. The first indication of any tension in the family is the reception of Gat by the grandparents who thinly veil their prejudice at this boy of Indian origins joining their perfect white family. As the children grow up and with Gat's influence, they question their family's privileged position, begin to see the tyrannical side of their grandfather and the hypocritical sides of their mothers. The atmosphere on the island slowly grows more claustrophobic, building up to Cady's swimming accident which leaves her with severe migraines and memory loss. As snapshots of memories return to Cady the plot unravels and her world frays into tatters. At the end we see clearly the tragedy of Cady's secret. The twist ending was as totally surprising and unexpected as it was devastating. This will appeal to teens and adults. 225 pages / Ages 12+ / Reviewed by Melanie Chadwick, school librarian.